LAW JOURNAL REPORTS. PART 6. JUNE, 1881. VOL. L. NEW SERIES. In the House of Lords, BIBLIOTHECA LIONEL LANCELOT SHADWELL, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. En the Privy Council, EDWARD BULLOCK, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. JUN 'F81 BODLEIANA En the Supreme Court of Judicature. ARTHUR CLEMENT EDDIS, H. LACY FRASER, WILLIAM ROBERT COLLYER, High Court of Justice. Crown Cases Reserved, WALTER HENRY MACNAMARA, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. Chancery Division, HENRY CHARLES DEANE, RICHARD BRAMWELL DAVIS, JOHN GENT, Queen's Bench Division, W. DECIMUS I. FOULKES, J. H. ETHERINGTON SMITH, GILBERT GEORGE KENNEDY, RICHARD HOLMDEN AMPHLETT, FRANCIS PARKER, Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Division, GEORGE CALLAGHAN and EDWARD STANLEY ROSCOE, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. In the London Court of Bankruptcy BEFORE THE CHIEF JUDGE, WILLIAM HARMOOD COCHRAN and ARTHUR CORDERY, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. EDITED BY MONTAGU CHAMBERS, ONE OF HER MAJESTY'S COUNSEL, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. CASES IN THE HOUSE OF LORDS, IN THE COURT OF APPEAL AND IN CHANCERY-page 369 to 448. QUEEN'S BENCH, COMMON PLEAS and EXCHEQUER-page 353 to 432. Printed by Spottiswoode & Co., Law Stationers, 87 Chancery Lane, and New-street Square, London. SINGLE NUMBER-PRICE FIVE SHILLINGS. [ 2 ] STEVENS AND HAYNES' LAW PUBLICATIONS. Now ready. Second Edition. 1 thick vol., 8vo. 42s. cloth extra. A MAGISTERIAL AND POLICE GUIDE. BEING THE STATUTE LAW, INCLUDING THE SESSION OF 43 VICT., 1880. With Notes and references to the most recently decided Cases, relating to the Procedure, Jurisdiction, and Duties of Magistrates and Police Authorities. With an Introduction, for the most part re-written, showing the General Procedure before Magistrates, both in Indictable and Summary Matters as altered by the Summary Jurisdiction Act, 1879 together with the Rules under the said Act. SECOND EDITION, BY HENRY C. GREENWOOD, Stipendiary Magistrate, & TEMPLE C. MARTIN, Chief Clerk, Lambeth Police Court. "Magistrates will find a valuable hand-book in 'Greenwood and Martin's Magisterial and Police Guide,' of which a fresh edition has just been published."-Times, January 27, 1881. "We are, moreover, convinced that no effort has been spared by its authors to render it a thoroughly efficient and trustworthy Guide."-Law Journal. "A second edition has appeared of Messrs. Greenwood & Martin's valuable and comprehensive Magisterial and Police Guide, a book which Justices of the Peace should take care to include in their libraries."-Saturday Review. "We have here our ideal law book. It may be said to omit nothing which it ought to contain.”—Law Times. Lately published, in 8vo., price 218. cloth. ENGLISH CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY From the Teutonic Invasion to the Present Time. Designed as a Text-Book for Students and Others. By T. P. TASWELL-LANGMEAD, Of Lincoln's Inn, Barrister-at-Law, late Tutor on Constitutional Law and Legal History to the Four Inns of Court, and formerly Vinerian Scholar in the University of Oxford. Second and enlarged edition, entirely revised, and in many parts rewritten. "We are glad to see a second edition of this valuable text book. Mr. Taswell-Langmead has always seemed to us to meet very well the requirements of the student. He is concise, comprehensive and careful, and his style is so easy that the general reader will find the book by no means unattractive. In the present edition the chapter on the Succession to the Crown has been remodelled, and the last chapter largely added to. As it now stands we should find it hard to name a better text book on English Constitutional History."-Solicitors' Journal. Now ready, Vol. III., price 20s., boards. REPORTS OF THE DECISIONS OF THE JUDGES FOR THE TRIAL OF ELECTION PETITIONS IN ENGLAND AND IRELAND. Pursuant to the Parliamentary Elections Act, 1868. By EDWARD LOUGHLIN O'MALLEY and HENRY HARDCASTLE. This Volume contains the Decisions of the Judges from August, 1874, to December, 1880. Vols. I. and II. can still be had. Now ready, in 8vo., price 5s. 6d., cloth. In 2 vols., royal 8vo., price 70s., cloth lettered. In 1 vol., 8vo., price 18s., cloth. PRINCIPLES OF CONVEYANCING. An THE LAW RELATING TO CHARITIES, In 1 vol., 8vo., price 9s., cloth. LEADING STATUTES SUMMARISED, for the use of Students. By ERNEST C. THOMAS, Bacon Scholar of the Hon. Society of Gray's Inn, late Scholar of Trinity College, Oxford, Author of "Leading Cases in Constitutional Law Briefly Stated." Now ready, in 8vo., price 18s., cloth. THE LAW and PRACTICE RELATING TO PETITIONS IN CHANCERY AND LUNACY. Including the Settled Estates Act, Lands Clauses Act, Trustee Act, Winding-up Petitions, Petitions relating to Solicitors, Infants, &c. With an Appendix of Forms and Precedents. By SYDNEY E. WILLIAMS, of Lincoln's Inn, Barrister-at-Law. "The book is furnished with a selection of forms and precedents; the arrangement of matter seems convenient, and we have found it easy to consult. We have not observed any important omission within the scope of the treatise; and the writer deserves the praise of having put together with some skill an unpretending work, which is at least more useful than certain larger law books we know of."-Solicitors' Journal. In 1 vol., 8vo., price 128., cloth. A COMPENDIUM OF ROMAN LAW FOUNDED on the INSTITUTES of JUSTINIAN; together with Examination Questions set in the University and Bar Examinations (with solutions), and definitions of leading terms in the words of the principal authorities. By GORDON CAMPBELL, of the Inner Temple, late Scholar of Exeter College, Oxford; M.A. Oxford and Cambridge; Author of "An Analysis of Austin's Jurisprudence." Third Edition, 1 vol., 8vo., price 25s., cloth. THE PROBATE, LEGACY, AND SUCCESSION DUTY ACTS, Incorporating the Cases to Michaelmas Sittings, 1876. By ALFRED HANSON, Esq., Comptroller of Legacy and Succession Duties. In 8vo., price 68., cloth. LEADING CASES in CONSTITUTIONAL LAW BRIEFLY STATED, with Introduction, Excursuses, and Notes. By ERNEST C. THOMAS, Bacon Scholar of the Hon. Society of Gray's Inn, late Scholar of Trinity College, Oxford. In 8vo., 1878, price 5s., cloth. A SUMMARY OF JOINT STOCK COMPANIES' LAW. By T. EUSTACE SMITH, Student of the Inner Temple. "Law Students may well read it; for Mr. Smith has very wisely been at the pains of giving his authority for all his statements of the law or of practice, as applied to joint-stock company business usually transacted in solicitors' chambers."-Law Times. London: STEVENS & HAYNES, Law Publishers, Bell Yard, Temple Bar. [Continued on p. 3 of Wrapper. LAW JOURNAL REPORTS. JOURNAL PART 7. JULY, 1881. VOL. L. NEW SERIES. En the House of Lords, LIONEL LANCELOT SHADWELL, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. En the Privy Council, EDWARD BULLOCK, BARRISTER-AT-LAW. In the Supreme Court of Judicature. ARTHUR CLEMENT EDDIS, H. LACY FRASER, WILLIAM ROBERT COLLYER, High Court of Justice. Crown Cases Reserved, WALTER HENRY MACNAMARA, BARRISTER-at-Law. Chancery Division, BIBLIJINERS JUL 81 HENRY CHARLES DEANE, RICHARD BRAMWELL DAVIS, JOHN GENT, JAMES E. HORNE, WILLIAM HARMOOD COCHRAN, ARTHUR CORDERY, CECIL C. M. DALE, GEORGE ABBOTT STREETEN and DAVID PITCAIRN, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. Queen's Bench Division, W. DECIMUS I. FOULKES, J. H. ETHERINGTON SMITH, GILBERT GEORGE KENNEDY, RICHARD HOLMDEN AMPHLETT, FRANCIS PARKER, and EDWARD BENNETT CALVERT, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. Probate, Divorce and Admiralty Division, GEORGE CALLAGHAN and EDWARD STANLEY ROSCOE, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. In the London Court of Bankruptcy BEFORE THE CHIEF JUDGE, WILLIAM HARMOOD COCHRAN and ARTHUR CORDERY, BARRISters-at-Law. EDITED BY MONTAGU CHAMBERS, ONE OF HER MAJESTY'S COUNsel, BARRISTERS-AT-LAW. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. CASES IN THE COURT OF APPEAL AND IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE. CHANCERY-page 449 to 528. QUEEN'S BENCH, COMMON PLEAS and EXCHEQUER-page 433 to 496. Printed by Spottiswoode & Co., Law Stationers, 87 Chancery Lane, and New-street Square, London. SINGLE NUMBER-PRICE FIVE SHILLINGS. STEVENS AND HAYNES' LAW PUBLICATIONS. Now ready. Second Edition. 1 thick vol., 8vo. 42s. cloth extra. A MAGISTERIAL AND POLICE GUIDE. BEING THE STATUTE LAW, INCLUDING THE SESSION OF 43 VICT., 1880. With Notes and references to the most recently decided Cases, relating to the Procedure, Jurisdiction, and Duties of SECOND EDITION, BY published."-Times, January 27, 1881. Justices of the Peace should take care to include in their libraries."-Saturday Review. ENGLISH CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY From the Teutonic Invasion to the Present Time. Designed as a Text-Book for Students and Others. By Just published, Fourth Edition, 8vo., price 12s., cloth. THE LAW OF FIXTURES, in the principal relation of Landlord and Tenant, and in all other or general relations. Fourth Edition. By A. BROWN, M.A., Barrister-at-Law. Now ready, in 8vo., price 2s. 6d., cloth. literally translated. Intended for the use of Students for all Legal Now ready, in 8vo., price 5s, 6d., cloth. SELF-PREPARATION for the INTER- MEDIATE EXAMINATION, as it exists on Stephen's Commentaries. Containing a complete course of study, with statutes, questions and advice, and intended for the use of all articled clerks who have not yet passed the intermediate examination. By JOHN INDERMAUR, Solicitor, Author of "Self-preparation for the Final," "Manual of Practice," "Principles of Common Law," &c. In 2 vols., royal 8vo., price 70s., cloth lettered. MASTERS and SEAMEN: their Appointment, Duties, Powers, Rights, Liabilities and Remedies. By JOSEPH KAY, Esq., M.A., Q.C., of the Northern Circuit; Solicitor-General of the County Palatine of Durham; one of the Judges of the Court of Record for the Hundred of Salford. Now ready, in 8vo., price 18s., cloth. TO PETITIONS IN CHANCERY AND LUNACY. Including the Settled Estates Act, Lands Clauses Act, Trustee Act, Winding-up Peti- tions, Petitions relating to Solicitors, Infants, &c. With an Appendix of Forms and Precedents. By SYDNEY E. WILLIAMS, of Lincoln's Inn, "The book is furnished with a selection of forms and precedents; the arrangement of matter seems convenient, and we have found it easy to consult. We have not observed any important omission within the scope of the treatise; and the writer deserves the praise of having put to- FOUNDED on the INSTITUTES of JUSTINIAN; together with principal authorities. By GORDON CAMPBELL, of the Inner Temple, Third Edition, 1 vol., 8vo., price 25s., cloth. CESSION DUTY ACTS, Incorporating the Cases to Michaelmas Sit- tings, 1876. By ALFRED HANSON, Esq., Comptroller of Legacy and A SUMMARY OF JOINT STOCK COM- "Law Students may well read it; for Mr. Smith has very wisely been at the pains of giving his authority for all his statements of the law or of practice, as applied to joint-stock company business usually transacted |