source request that they indicate which of the books There have been other important develop- It is hoped that this will prove to be only development of closer contacts with related Special mention should be made of the de- Service on International Affairs. The publi- cation of the first volume of the European of information on European in keeping them informed as to European official publications, and in securing these publications when desired. It is hoped that this side of the work will be developed more and more, as American libraries realize the unique character of the service which is offered. The recent compilation of a bibliog- raphy of the official publications of all the governments of Europe is a work of unusual importance to all libraries. BURTON E. STEVENSON, Director, American Library in Paris. COMMITTEE REPORTS, 1925-26 libraries. The effort is to increase the located copies in the Union Catalog as far as possible and organize the increase of this stock by purchasing agreement of libraries on the basis of the list of special collections. It is follow- ing the line approved by the Council at the Atlantic City meeting. The work on Union Catalog and special collections is international cooperation in the sense that the League com- rying out its own share in such matters and recommendations. Bibliographies in process. On initiative of a member of this Committee the Library of Congress has undertaken to open a single cumulative registration file of bibliographies operation is desired from all who know of noteworthy bibliographies existing in manu- at date of the communication. E. C. RICHARDSON, Chairman. BOARD OF EDUCATION FOR LIBRARIANSHIP The report of the Board of Education for Librarianship with appendixes was printed separately for distribution at the Fiftieth Anniversary Conference. (Printed in full pages 405-473.) ADAM STROHM, Chairman. BOOKBINDING the status of library binders in various sections has been published. The American Library The two bookbinding exhibits were thor- Association appeared twice in opposition, suboughly overhauled early in the year before mitting a formal brief in answer, paragraph being sent out on their usual itineraries among by paragraph, to the publishers' printed statelibrary schools. Revision of some publications ment, and introducing the following organizaof the Bookbinding Committee, including Care tions, which appointed spokesmen to particiof books in libraries, Specifications for strong pate: American Association of University edition work for large books of the reference Professors, American Chemical Society, type, and Preparation of periodicals for bind- American Council on Education, American ing, is in process. Historical Association, American PhilologA rather carefully planned exhibit was pre- ical Association, American Physical Society, pared under supervision of the chairman for Archæological Institute of America, Associathe Sesquicentennial at Philadelphia, to be tion of American Colleges, Association of included in the A. L. A. exhibit there. Urban Universities, College Art Association, The question of better paper for the more Geological Society of America, Linguistic worthy books has demanded some attention, Society of America, Modern Language Assothe ideal paper for such books of permanent ciation of America, and the National Educaimportance being obviously one hundred per tion Association. The Register of Copyrights, cent rag quality, although this ideal is still far endorsed by the Committee on Copyright of from being realized. The issue in February the American Bar Association, presented an of the special autographed rag paper edition extended comparison between the two bills, of Carl Sandburg's Abraham Lincoln came as highly unfavorable to H. R. 10434. recognition by its publishers, Harcourt, Brace The libraries are chiefly affected by the proand Company, of the need of preservation of visions regarding the importation of foreign the real literature of the present day. The publications. Under existing law, they may fact that the demand early exceeded the limits bring in any legitimate issue. The Perkins of this special edition gives assurance of the bill allows the publisher of an American book support of such efforts towards better paper to forbid the entrance of a foreign (though for high class books of permanent value, not authorized) reprint. The Vestal bill repeats only by libraries but by the more discrim this, but goes further and requires that orders inating book buyers among the general trade. for the original edition of a foreign work in MARY E. WHEELOCK, Chairman, English reprinted here be sent to the AmerJOHN ARCHER, J. R. GULLEDGE, ican publisher, and the provision is retroactJOSEPH FULTON, GERTRUDE STILES. ive, though used copies, foreign newspapers and magazines, foreign language books, collecBOOK BUYING tions en bloc, travelers' books, motion pictures Copyright continued to claim major atten- and motion-picture photoplays, raised print, tion this year, and some ameliorative legisla- and works for the United States are made tion resulted, though no general measure exempt—none explains why. passed in the first session of the 69th Con- If such restrictions, which have no countergress. The Perkins bill, prepared in the Copy- part the world over, were enacted into law, right Office, was reintroduced as H. R. 5841, and could be enforced (which seems problemon December 17, 1925, though its sponsor did atical), no one could safely order an English not press for further consideration. But ex book from abroad, if published within the past actly three months later, Chairman Albert H. fifty-six years or until the author is a half Vestal, of the House Committee on Patents, century dead, without first ascertaining (from offered in H. R. 10434 a substitute, prepared the Copyright Office) whether there be an by commercial interests, especially the motion American edition and then asking the reprinter picture industry and the book publishers, who if his edition is in stock. Otherwise, he might had succeeded in pressing the Authors' League find himself a smuggler and his consignment to compromise. confiscated. Then upon arrival the Custom This was brought to hearing for four days Houses must make the same inquiries. The design is to discourage importation and foster released and it is hoped that no other will be reprinting, with the public paying the double put to such annoyance. bill. The price maintenance bill appeared once The outstanding result of these hearings more in this Congress, under its familiar numwas the compromise struck between the music ber H. R. 11, introduced by Rep. Clyde Kelly, composers on the one hand, and on the other of Pennsylvania. It provided, “That in conthe mechanical reproducers—the phonograph, tracts relating to the sale or resale of an artimotion picture and radio groups, so that in the cle of commerce, the genuineness of which is next session the representatives of the buying attested by the trade mark or special brand public will find themselves confronted, as of any grower, producer, manufacturer or usual, with a solid phalanx of those with other trade mark proprietor ... it shall be something to sell, but our entrance into the lawful for ... vendees (i. e retailers) to International Copyright Union seems measur- agree to sell such articles at the prices preably nearer. scribed by such vendor and such agreements The inch of progress actually attained in shall not be construed as against public policy legislation was copyright protection to works or in restraint of trade or in violation of the produced by processes other than typesetting, Act of Congress of July 2, 1890, or of any of photo-engraving or lithography, which are the Acts supplemental thereto.” This covers alone recognized in the present law. This trade-marked articles. The publishers, who concerns mimeographed issues especially. This did not participate in the hearings of April amendment, which we actively pressed through 22 and 23, are seeking to have the bill amended the Senate in its closing hours, will particu so as to cover copyrighted books. The booklarly aid teachers who use this method of try- sellers appeared in advocacy and found theming out their texts before committing them selves opposed by the counsel who had sucto type. cessfully fought the celebrated Macy cases, which led to the dissolution of the old AmerThe old marking law controversy broke out anew this year. It will be recalled that every ican Publishers' Association, with assessment tariff act since 1890 has had a provision requir of $140,000 damages. Librarians will do well ing that imported goods be conspicuously to keep their eyes on this regularly recurring marked to show country of origin. Till 1922, bill, for there lies in it the threatened cancel lation of discounts, which the publishers' so far as books were concerned, the imprint was accounted compliance. But it was then organ is steadily urging. alleged that certain American publishers had The Committee this year continued to issue been printing abroad and concealing the fact. bulletins in the library periodicals—six of So the Treasury rendered a decision that the them. As at present organized, it has put out title-page should be the place of record. The a total of forty-four. unexpected result of this was that the New M. LLEWELLYN RANEY, Chairman, York Custom House ruled against admitting Carl L. CANNON, HILLER C. WELLMAN, books unless they carried such a phrase as Asa Don DICKINSON, PURD B. WRIGHT. "Printed in England,” etc., and library shipments were held up. Protests steadily repeated BOOK PRODUCTION brought a new instruction exempting “public The purpose of this Committee is admirably libraries or library associations" when im stated in the resolution of the Council directporting “for their own use and not for sale.” ing its appointment as a standing committee All library shipments were accordingly re- of the A. L. A. The resolution (adopted July leased at once and importations have moved 10, 1925) reads: smoothly ever since, till, of a sudden, some "That the Council request the Executive Philadelphia official made the discovery that Board to appoint a standing committee on college and university libraries are not "pub- Book Production whose duties shall be to prolic," and so assessed a fine against two impor mote the use of better paper and better typog. tant institutions, but since it could be readily raphy for books of permanent importance, the Committee to cooperate with the Bookbinding proven that their reference collections were Committee, other committees and organizasubject to any citizen's use, the shipments were tions and to report to the Council annually." The appointments to the Committee were not formally announced until the spring of 1926. Although letters asking for suggestions were sent to the Committee members, by the chairman, as soon as practicable, it proved too late to reach two of them and receive their comments before their departure for vacation. This has left too narrow a margin of time to present an elaborate report. Such a report should be an epitome of all the suggestions of the whole Committee as agreed upon by them after adequate deliberation. This preliminary report, therefore, includes only the summarized suggestions received from the five members of the Committee who could be reached in time to receive their criticisms on the preliminary draft of the report. It is evident that the Committee must recognize three distinct types of persons: (1) the book-makers as represented by the publisher, the printer and the binder; (2) the distributors of books as represented by the bookseller and the librarian and, (3) the users of books as represented by the book buyer and the library patron. The interests of all are closely related. The publisher will not issue books he cannot sell nor can the printer and binder continue to manufacture books at a loss. The bookseller must be able to sell at a reasonable profit the books produced, and the librarian must be able to get them at prices within his institutional resources. The book buyer likewise must be able to buy the book he admires as a piece of good bookmaking or be able to have access to it in a library which does have the means to buy it. There are also very evidently two kinds of public to consider: (1) the discriminating public, which sees in the book a work of art which is, to a great degree, enjoyable in proportion as it is well made in accordance with artistic principles and, (2) the mass of readers to whom typographic art is not a matter of as much moment as is something to read. Until library resources are much more generally distributed in more adequate amounts the question of getting books at all is likely to loom larger than getting only those of pleasing appearance One member of the committee, Miss Barrette, stresses the point that most exhibits of good printing, as shown in the books included, stress the exceptional successes rather than the effects to be produced within a moderate price range. Their appeal is, consequently, much less than it should be. It is encouraging that the recent traveling exhibit of the American Institute of Graphic Arts included a very fair number of inexpensive books quite within the reach of the average library. Several of these were admirable models for library publications. Fortunately, there is no essential conflict between the two types of appeal or the two publics. The phrase "of permanent importance" is very elastic in its interpretation. It includes both cheap and expensive books. It ranges from the World almanac to Morison's ponderous folios of typographic models. Even cheap books can be made to look better than most of them do. A knowledge of what good book-making is will enable the head of even the smallest library to get at least some better looking books “of permanent value" at little or no increase of cost. It will be some time before even the majority of library books are a credit to the printer and the binder. That should be all the more reason for attempting as much improvement as is practicable. It should be possible and it would certainly be desirable to adopt the suggestion of Mr. Wellman that direct attempts be made to educate librarians as to the characteristics of good printing so that they could more confidently judge books on their typographic merits. Occasional special bulletins, articles in library periodicals, and the inclusion in A. L. A. programs of occasional addresses and papers are possible and practical. Mr. Cleland's talk at the Berkeley conference in 1915 is cited by Mr. Wellman as an example. The well-made book has an artistic appeal that, from the wide circulation of books and magazines, could be made nation-wide in its influence. In most cases the well-made book has an economic value in lasting longer, and it is likely to receive better treatment. Keeping these things in mind, it should be possible for publishers to receive better library support for better-produced books. Quantity production can be made to serve art by reducing the cost of each unit. The fact that librarians rather generally have been a little loath to commit themselves to guaranteed support of any project of the kind is not necessarily a reason why they should continue to be so. If the |