« PreviousContinue »
Space does not permit a more extended review of this initial volume. In the range of national laws referred to, in the voluminous citations of adjudicated cases, and in the wealth of literature subjected to analysis, the work is as conspicuously important as it is on account of the author's candor in discussion and in his independence of judgment. With the succeeding volumes' promise and an adequate index, the work of M. Travers will indeed prove to be one of commanding value.
JESSE S. REEVES.
Grundzüge des Positiven Völkerrechts. By Dr. Karl Strupp. Bonn: Verlag
Ludwig Röhrscheid, 1921, pp. viii, 251.
An undertaking to state "the positive, actually effective, present international law” in the year 1921 would seem to require an unusual degree of confidence and courage. Dr. Strupp's book is a condensation of his lectures on international law delivered at the University of Frankfurt during the Winter Semester of 1920–1921. It is interesting to note that the book is one of a series published under the title of "Der Staatsburger" for the purpose of educating the German people in their new responsibilities of citizenship. However commendable the purpose, it seems doubtful if international law is capable of being so simplified and popularized—as has been attempted here in the brief compass of 250 pages—as to make such a text of any real value. Certainly from a scientific point of view, the treatment must be inadequate.
The plan of the book is orderly and the development logical, as one expects from a writer of Dr. Strupp's scholarly attainments. But the great body of the text might as well have been written in 1914; and, except for a parenthetical clause or a minor reference here and there, it is but a statement of the “law as it aforetime was.” No adequate account is taken of the changed situation and the effects of the violent disturbances of the last few years in the society of nations. For example, the whole topic of neutrality is treated in a most fragmentary way by a recital of the provisions in the conventions of the Hague Peace Conferences; the discussion of naval warfare is largely a recapitulation of the unratified Declaration of London of 1909, including three pages of the specific articles enumerated in that obsolete instrument under the title of Contraband. That title certainly is not now if it ever was international law.
The book is especially valuable for its documentation and historical references. Dr. Strupp's great contribution to our profession in making source material available is reflected in this book. On the whole, one must admire Dr. Strupp's objective treatment. He declares ruthless submarine warfare per se unlawful and permissible only in case of "Notstand” or reprisal (page 215), which seems a cryptic and inconclusive statement-all the more so in view of the author's definition of "Notstand” as given on page 130: "Notstand, in international law, is a condition in which a state faces an instant and immediately threatening great danger, preventable only by injury to the rights of others, which danger would, under a reasonable consideration, imperil the existence, territory or people of the state or its independence to such an extent that its legal capacity to act internationally would likely be abolished or, at least, reduced to a minimum."
On page 205, Dr. Strupp says that the recent war “left the rules of naval warfare, perhaps also of land warfare, if not indeed the whole system of international law, in a state of chaos." He evidently recognizes the problem but does not show us the path to order. As a conventional restatement of former rules, the book, on the whole, is well written history but it is not "positive, actually effective law.”'
GEORGE C. BUTTE.
The Policy of the United States as regards Intervention. By Charles E. Mar
tin. New York: Longmans, Green & Co., 1921, pp. 173.
In this monograph of four chapters the author clearly traces the origin and adoption of the American cardinal policy of non-intervention, and the extension of the principle to its new phase of application to the independent states of America, and also explains the two most striking departures from the principle, in relation to American states and territory, in the cases of Cuba and Panama.
In reviewing the factors entering into the formation of the policy Dr. Martin treats rather fully the policies of the Revolution resulting in the expedient treaty of alliance of 1778, and later experiences under this alliance which brought the United States face to face with the question of interference in European affairs and through various tests pointed the way to the adoption of non-intervention as a practical policy. But quite ap from the influence of practical questions in the evolution of the policy he partly explains the existence of a theory of non-intervention to a conscious purpose resulting from geographical isolation and the conception of the right of revolution.
In the chapter on extension of the American policy, he presents, as actual cases abundantly establishing the principle of non-intervention as a definite policy, many of the chief diplomatic problems in Latin American relations: the Mississippi and Florida problems; the recognition of the Spanish American republics, the Monroe doctrine (and its antecedents), the American policy of non-alliance with Latin American states, American opposition to foreign intervention in Mexico on various occasions (to 1867), American concern and policy in connection with various international controversies of Venezuela (in 1860, 1871, 1895, and 1902–03), incidents in relations of Brazil (1825 and 1893-94), relations with Argentine (1828, 1832–41 and 1898), relations with Chile (1891 and 1893), the attempted intervention of Secretary Blaines in the Chile-Peruvian war in 1881 and the later reversion of Frelinghuysen to the policy of reserve and caution which radically changed the result of the war. Excepting the general right to intervene for protection of the rights and safety of its citizens, he concludes that American policy has been understood "to preclude the United States from intervening in the internal politics of American states" and "to preclude European states from intervening in the western hemisphere either to gain territory or to change the political system or control the destiny of American nations.”
In discussing the factors resulting in the extension of the policy, he emphasizes the fact that each extension was made to meet the demands of new sets of circumstances.
In the third chapter the author traces the chief diplomatic instances illustrating American interest and policy in Cuba from 1808 to 1898; and in the fourth he traces the American policy in Panama, especially in its relation to the treaty of 1846 with New Grenada. He explains that each of these interventions was limited primarily to protection of American interests and led to the establishment of an independent state and an arrangement for guarantees of independence.
The volume has a synoptical table of contents and footnote references to authorities used, but has no index.
Dr. Martin has reserved for future publication the recent special situations in Santo Domingo, Nicaragua and Hayti-involving an American supervision which non-American powers would be forbidden to exercise, and which in its development (the author says) is not likely to ignore the purposes and limits of the distinguishing principle of American foreign policy.
J. M. CALLAHAN.
A Manual of International Law. By Rear Admiral C. H. Stockton, U. S.
Navy. Second revised edition. Annapolis: U. S. Naval Institute, 1921, 355 pp.
The value of this manual is proved by the fact that the original and one revised edition have become exhausted. The author is the foremost naval authority on international law in the United States, and as such his presentation of the subject carries a weight with those for whose use the book is particularly written that no work by an author without naval experience can be expected to exercise. As was so well said by the late General Davis in his review of the first edition, it “represents the experience gained in the practice of International Law by its author during a long and especially useful career as an officer of the United States Navy; a career which may be said to have culminated in his fortunate incumbency of the office of Superintendent (President) of the Naval War College."
The general scope and arrangement of the manual remain unchanged, as does most of the text. The occurrence of the World War between the issues of the first and the present editions could not fail to be the occasion of many notices in the revision in appropriate places. Similarly the issuance of instructions by the Navy Department for the government of the U. S. Navy in maritime war in June, 1917, after the first revision of the manual, has been the occasion of additions and revisions. One change in form more than in substance is the separation in paragraphs and captions of the subjects of the destruction of enemy and of neutral prizes. It is worthy of mention because too often it is very difficult to know from their texts to which form of destruction writers are referring.
In a supplementary chapter Admiral Stockton, in addition to the revisions of the text, discusses the changes naturally occurring in the decade since the manual was first written, -changes emphasized by the greatest war in history. The captions of the Chapter include "Cutting of Cables, “Radio-Telegraphy," "Neutrality Laws," "Internment of Vessels," "Armed Merchantmen," "So-called Blockade of Germany" and "Right of Angary," which sufficiently indicates the general ground covered.
To the appendices of the original edition have been added the President's neutrality proclamation occasioned by the war between Great Britain and Germany (which had as issued a curious typographical omission of several lines that made new law as that part of the proclamation actually read, which omission was corrected in later proclamations), and the sections of the Revised Statutes governing the capture, sending in and the destruction of prizes. Sample forms of a Certificate of Registry, a Consolidated Certificate of Enrollment and License, and a License of Vessel under Twenty Tons are included.
In the form of this up-to-date revision the manual, whose usefulness has been so well demonstrated, will be of increased value to the clientele for whom it is especially written, as it will to others who have not the time or opportunity to consult more exhaustive treaties on International Law.
H. S. KNAPP.
The Proceedings of the Hague Peace Conferences. Translation of the official
texts. Prepared in the Division of International Law of the Carnegie
The Conference of 1899. 1920. pp. xxii, 882.
lxxi, 81, 1086. Vol. III. Meetings of the Second, Third and Fourth Com
missions. 1921. pp. xci, 1162. Index volume covering the preceding volumes. pp. 272. These sumptuous volumes contain the first complete English version of the Proceedings of the Hague Peace Conferences of 1899 and 1907, the original and official French versions of which have become somewhat difficult to procure. This edition in five volumes will be adopted as a definitive English edition of the Proceedings of the Hague Conferences. The translation appears in all respects to have been carefully and sympathetically made. No extended review of the contents is necessary. The index volume, prepared in the Division of International Law, makes it possible for the first time readily to turn to any part of the Proceedings. There is an index of persons and a general index by which any idea may be followed from its original expression in the Commission, Sub-commission or Plenary Session, to its final statement in the definitive conventions. The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace has put all students of international law under lasting obligation in carrying to completion this admirably conceived enterprise and in putting forth the work in a manner which is justified by its significance and importance.
J. S. REEVES.
The British Year Book of International Law, 1921-22. London: Henry
Frowde and Hodder & Stoughton, 1921, pp. viii, 272. 168. net.
This volume is the second issue of this publication and contains articles, notes on international events, digest of cases, list of international agreements from January 1, 1920-May 31, 1921, book reviews and an extensive bibliography of publications dealing with subjects of international interest.
The first two articles discuss the jurisdiction of the Permanent Court of International Justice, and are written by Sir H. Erle Richards, Professor of International Law and Diplomacy at Oxford University, and by Dr. D. C. J. Loder, of The Netherlands, who has recently been elected President of the Permanent Court of International Justice. The article by Dr. Loder is of particular interest as he reviews the stormy career of the proposal that