Page images
PDF
EPUB

She displayed good financial instinct, for she asked, "Are the investments recommended by H. L. Barber & Co., such that I would be safe in investing money in any of them."

Now the Financial Editor, in giving advice. regarding securities of new companies, always applies the Morgan method to determine whether they should be given any consideration at all by investors. A partner, of J. P. Morgan & Co., when asked how they investigated all the new enterprises into which they put money, unless they employed a thousand men tc do it, once replied: "We don't investigate; we back the men who manage them." This case was particularly easy to handle because the woman had disclosed an understanding of this most important consideration in the making of investments. The reply was to have nothing at all to do with this offering, or with any other offering of the same concern. The Financial Editor knew the record of H. L. Barber; knew, for instance, that he had been indicted for fraudulent use of the mails, in connection with the flotation of the Consolidated Midway Chief Oil Company stock, his arrest having occurred early in 1915 and the case being still pending on a demurrer before Judge Geiger of Milwaukee. He also knew that of many companies which Barber had promoted few if any were paying dividends.

The point to be made, however, is that it is not generally necessary to know the past record of such men in order to decide regarding their offerings. That helps, of course, but nearly always the "literature" sent out to "prospects" bears on the face of it one or more of the distinguishing earmarks of the get-rich-quick promoters' methods. By becoming familiar with these methods the investor himself can recognize many of the things he should not touch. This kind of promoter, when he is successful, that is, when he keeps out of jail, is generally shrewd enough not to put false statements in his circulars. That would lead to trouble with the Federal Post Office authorities. But he has found he doesn't need to. He can stick close to the truth when he talks about what has been done; but elaborates on intentions, estimates, and promises until he has painted a picture that draws a stream of money from trustful investors. The widow in Nebraska was being asked to invest her $10,000 before there was even a factory started. There was no misrepresentation on that point. The frankness of this particular Barber cir

cular would be humorous if the sad side of the whole business was not so apparent. Although parts for the tractor were to be manufactured in a foundry and machine shop, the president could write to Barber, for his use in selling the stock, that "we are fortunate in that the material situation which is hampering other manufacturers cannot handicap our production because of the class of material we use." The answer may be that they will use little material and do very little manufacturing. This can stand beside the frank statement of the George Alot Land Company, which a few years ago sold farms located in the bed of the Mississippi River. They said that the land was "unimproved except for running water."

A favorite device of the get-rich-quick game is illustrated by this recent "Report of Progress" of the Convertible Tractor Corporation. After informing the prospect that the financing is going forward "so rapidly that in little more than a month after we began the work the management was getting ready to begin commercial production of the Megow convertible tractor," the promoter publishes a letter from Mr. C. F. Megow which informs him that "from this date on I will devote all my time and strength to make a great success for the Convertible Tractor Corporation, and do from now on conclude all other connections.” As much money has been fraudulently pumped from the pockets of would-be investors by the use of names in this way as by any other trick of the trade. The Ford Tractor Company furnished an excellent example of this. Before that company and its "bankers" where caught in the Government's net, the New York Tribune had shown how the promoters went down the list of Fords in the Minneapolis telephone directory and stopped at that of Paul B. Ford, who was found willing to father the new company. That name helped to separate more than 3,000 people from about $350,000.

There is so much similarity in the "literature" sent out by the get-rich-quick promoters that, with a little training, one can spot it at a glance. This tractor circular was by no means one of Barber's best. Only once did he impress the need of buying early in order to get in before the shares were all gone. Robert P. Matches & Co., the promoters of the Ford Tractor Company, in offering that "chance of a lifetime," used nine paragraphs of an eighteen-paragraph letter to urge the

necessity of immediate purchase. The fact that Government officials were so close on their trail may have accounted for this great demand for haste. Mr. Barber, however, is usually confident that his offerings will be oversubscribed and urges that the public come in and share equally in the profits with those who "have carried the business forward to the splendid success now indicated." And especially they should buy the shares "while they may be had at the present low price." Don't wait until a few days for the higher price of the next offering. Get yours Now."

H. L. Barber & Co. is used as an illustration because Mr Barber's operations in this field of finance have lately been mentioned in letters from WORLD'S WORK readers more frequently than have those of others of his kind. The point to be impressed, however, is that the methods of all of them are much the same, although some are more clever than others in applying them. A shrewd lawyer is usually employed to see that the promoter keeps just within the law in his "literature."

An excellent example of one of the oldest and most fruitful methods is to be found in Mr. Barber's letter on "Coffeetone." This method might take its name from his first sentence: "History repeats itself." A graphic account is given of the advance of C. W. Post and the Postum Cereal Company from a capital of $750 in 1895 to $33,000,000 in eighteen years. A cut of the little barn in which Post started, compared with the present plant of twenty large buildings, adds the visual proof of the success of that business. Then, after personalizing this by telling of an individual who invested $1,000 in the Postum Company in 1896 and has had $54,374 profit since, "according to his information," Mr. Barber goes on to tell how Coffeetone is so treated as to "keep out of it the bad taste and smell that characterize all other substitutes." In another instance, to show that "fifteen dollars may make you very comfortable if put it at work in the Commonwealth Pictures Corporation-Right Now, not next month," Mr. Barber tells what "the reports indicate that $15 of original capital in the Pullman Company and the Gillette Safety Razor Company has grown to. "These," he says, "are simply indications of what $15 has done and is doing in companies." He does not say it will do as well in his latest promotion, but "on the other hand, it has what you will concede to be a good chance to

do as well or better." In the case of the Boulder Tungsten Production Company, he says: "I would not be fair to a prospective investor if I failed to say that I do believe it has good possibilities of just as great a success, if not greater."

This method of appealing to the cupidity in human nature is as old as the hills, and the one most often used by get-rich-quick promoters. Said a thieving broker years ago: "Promise 6 per cent. dividends on a first-class security, and you cannot do business; but promise 56 per cent on a fake, and I can get rich. If the Post Office Department would only let me alone, I would have to hire a cart to carry down my money-laden mail."

Barber has an advantage over most promoters, for he publishes a magazine-“Investing for Profit." The subscription rate is a dollar a year, but advertisements in certain papers recently offered lady agents 30 to 35 cents for each subscription secured at 50 to 69 cents. He will even send it for six months free. Thus he gains new names for his "sucker list." He claims the magazine has the largest "exclusively financial" circulation in America, whatever that means. It is certainly an important part in his remarkably efficient system for parting people from their money. A recent number contained an editorial by Mr. Barber on no less pretentious a subject than "The Law of Financial Success." Benjamin Franklin and Abraham Lincoln were quoted on the front page and Woodrow Wilson and others inside.

The remainder was largely thinly disguised promotion propaganda under such titles as "Be an Insider' not an 'Outsider,"" "The Small Investor's Chance," "Advice of the Money-Trust's Publications," this latter being an explanation of why a large number of magazines and newspapers speak disparagingly of many forms of "investments.' This word "investments" is, of course, overworked in connection with his offerings. Having thus properly prepared the reader's mind, he then proceeds to discuss the need for farm tractors, with particular reference to the Convertible Tractor Corporation. The Maibohm Motors Company is also given special treatment, with "estimated" profits per car and per share of stock on the basis of "planned" production. The great things in store for the motion picture industry and for the Commonwealth Pictures Corporation in particular are given proper space. A most promising report on "Cof

feetone" is drawn from a letter from the presi-
All his current flota-
dent of the company.
tions are thus recommended to his readers in a
publication that poses as "A Guide to Making
Money." On the first page, however, it is
stated in small type that no responsibility is
assumed for accuracy of statements published
therein. In the back pages are news items
designed to keep the purchasers of earlier flota-
tions in an expectant mood. A long list of
dividend declarations is published, but among
them there are no Barber promotions. Thus
this self-styled "Schoolmaster of the Science of
Investment," who has written a book on "Mak-
ing Money Make Money, A Primer of In-
vesting," plays the promotion game and has
become rich at it.

You ask why the Post Office Department
permits such a man and dozens of others with
records as bad to continue offering their wares
broadcast through the mails. The reason
seems to be that they may be promoting some-
thing that will turn out well. The law as it
stands does not permit the exclusion from the
mails of any offering unless and until there is
sufficient evidence to prove that it is a fraud.
Every time the promoter must be given the
. benefit of the doubt. He must be considered
honest no matter what his previous record.
The Postmaster-General could rule him out of
the mails, but the Department must be ready
to go into the courts in the case of each offering
and prove that there is intent to defraud.
Frequently by the time incriminating evidence
is gathered the flotation of the stock is com-
pleted and the public possesses all the hand-
some certificates. The promoter may later
go to jail, and thus society be rid of him for a
time; but more often he gets off with a fine
and immediately starts a new promotion.

Then there is the large volume of flotations
that are of little or no value, but where it might
be impossible to prove intent to defraud, and
where the shrewd promoter has to make no
false statements to sell the stock. These help
to swell the total of worthless issues in which
to estimates,
Americans lose, according to
$1,000,000 a day. With a new one born every
minute-it seems faster of late-and with the
name of a "once-sold" prospect valued more
highly than others by the promoters, who pay
good prices for their "sucker lists," the great
need for educating the public is apparent.
More is being done than ever before to protect
investors from their own foolishness, but fools

and their money continue to part soon and
probably always will.

The National Vigilance Committee of the As-
sociated Advertising Clubs of the World is do-
ing excellent work in running down the crooks.
Mr. Merle Sidener, of Indianapolis, is chairman
of this committee which, through the 170
Vigilance Committees of the different clubs
throughout the country, and with the aid
of expert counsel, has gathered conclusive evi-
dence in many cases of fraud against the public.
In the field of finance, the nipping of the Em-
erson Motor, the Ford Tractor, and other large
stock-promotion schemes before they had
wreaked the full ruin intended on the public
can be credited to a considerable extent to this
committee. Because of the material aid it
gives, the Government officials are frequently
able to draw in their net much sooner than they
would be otherwise. The Investment Bankers
Association of America recently established a
committee on fraudulent advertising which
will work along the same lines, probably in
conjunction with the National Vigilance Com-
There are many newspapers and mag-
mittee.
azines which, by carefully scrutinizing the ad-
vertising they accept, assist in saving the in-
vestor's money. There are also some which
carefully investigate and do not hesitate to
label worthless security issues. The Financial
World is worthy of mention in this particular,
for it has for many years fearlessly exposed
get-rich-quick promoters and their methods,
in a column appropriately entitled “The
Fairyland of Finance."

At this time, when the United States needs eighteen billion dollars by June 30th nextmore than four times what Great Britain spent in her first year of war, and more every two days than the entire fortune left by the late J. P. Morgan-it would be highly proper that some drastic means be taken to prevent the waste of funds in worthless securities. It is now more of a national problem than ever before. Mr. Charles H. Sabin, president of the Guaranty Trust Co. of New York, has suggested that it might be advisable to appoint a Government board to pass on the priority of public financial offerings, in order to reserve for the Government the first call on the savings of the Nation. That might be a means of solving the fake stock promotion evil, at least for the period of the war. Out of such temporary solution might possibly come something of permanent value.

WITH THE BELGIAN KING AND QUEEN

AT LA PANNE

"The King Stood Beside the Table

It Was the Saddest Face One Can

Imagine, But Not a Word of Complaint Was Breathed"

"The Queen

Was Still Full of Courage and Said That as Long as There Was One
Square Foot of Belgian Soil Free of Germans, She Would Be on It"

BY

HUGH GIBSON

[Formerly First Secretary of the American Legation in Brussels]

[In this article, Mr. Gibson describes his meeting with the King and Queen of the Belgians after the Belgian army had retired from Antwerp. At this meeting the King and Queen wrote their appeals to the American people for aid. Mr. Gibson also describes his conferences in London with the American and Spanish Ambassadors, Mr. Hoover, and others, at which the plans for rationing Belgium were laid out and Mr. Hoover undertook the work. These historic episodes are selected from Mr. Gibson's book, “A Journal from Our Legation in Belgium," just published.—The Editors.]

B

RUSSELS, October 14, 1914.-We are quite up in the air about what we are to do next. Monday afternoon I went around to headquarters to get a laisser-passer to take Harold Fowler [now a major in the United States Army], back to England. While the matter was being attended to, an officer came in and told me that Baron von der Lancken wanted very much to see me. When I went into his room, he said that there was nothing in particular that he wanted to see me about, but that he thought I would be interested in hearing the news and in telling him something of my trip. We talked along for some time about things in general and then he told me that the movement of troops toward the coast was progressing rapidly and that the Belgian Government would soon be driven from the country. Then, putting the tips of his fingers together and looking me coyly in the eye, he inquired: "And then, my dear colleague, what will be your position?" He elaborated by pointing out that, the Government to which we are accredited having left the country, we would be merely in the position of foreigners of distinction residing here, and that we would have no official rank or standing. The idea evidently is that they do not care to have us around any longer than they can help.

I later learned that Villalobar had been more ready than I with his retort. In the course of a call later in the afternoon Lancken

had talked the same matter over with him, and had wound up with the same genial question: "And then, my dear colleague, what will be your position?" Without any hesitation, Villalobar replied: "My situation will be just the same as yours. We are both representa-. tives of our country in a country not our own. We shall continue to owe each other respect, and to make the best of conditions."

The latest news we have to-day is to the effect that the Government has been driven from Ostend, presumably to the Isle of Guernsey.

To-day I ran across an order from the Governor-General forbidding civilians to ride bicycles. The order concludes as follows:

Civilians who, in spite of this, continue to ride bicycles, expose themselves to being shot by German troops.

If a cyclist is suspected of planning to damage railroad, telegraph or telephone lines, or of the intention of attacking German troops, he will be shot according to martial law.

Apparently it is no longer necessary to go through the forms of proving that the cyclist had any evil intention. The mere suspicion is enough to have him shot.

In the course of a visit to General von Lüttwitz to-day, one of the colleagues remarked that the Germans must keep the Belgians. alive, and could not allow them to starve. Lüttwitz was not at all of that mind, for he said, with some show of feeling:

[ocr errors]

"The Allies are at liberty to feed the Belgians. If they don't they are responsible for anything that may happen. If there are bread riots, the natural thing would be for us to drive the whole civil population into some restricted area, like the Province of Luxemburg, build a barbed wire fence around them, and leave them to starve in accordance with the policy of their allies."

And as the German policy is more or less frankly stated as a determination to wipe out as many of the enemy as possible without regard to what is or has been considered as permissible, it is quite within the realm of possibility that they would be prepared to let the Belgian people starve. In any event, you can't gamble with the lives of seven millions of people when all you have to go on is the belief that Germany will be guided by the dictates of humanity.

I have had enough of ruined towns, and was not able to get the awful sights out of my head all night, but spent my time in bad dreams. From Vilvorde right into Antwerp there is not a town intact. Eppeghem, Sempst, Malines, Waelhem, Berchem-all razed to the ground. In Malines a good part of the town is standing, and I suppose that the Cathedral can be restored, but the other towns are done for. There were practically no civilians in any of them a few poor peasants poking dismally about in the ruins, trying to find some odds and ends that they could save from the general wreck. There were some children sitting on the steps of deserted houses and a few hungry dogs prowling around, but no other signs of life. All the way from the outskirts of Brussels straight through to Antwerp, the road was lined with empty bottles. They gave a pretty good idea of what had gone on along the line of march.

The bombardment of Antwerp lasted from the afternoon that we left up to Friday noon. The damage is pretty evenly distributed. Houses here and there in every street were badly smashed and the whole block across the street from the Hôtel St. Antoine, where we stayed, was burned to the ground. The Cathedral was not damaged.

When we were there last week, the streets were thronged with people and with motors. Yesterday there was not a soul to be seen for blocks together. The town was practically deserted.

This morning the Committee for the Provisioning of Brussels came in, and asked whether

I was prepared to go to London for them and
endeavor to arrange for some sort of permanent
agreement with the British Government for
the provisioning of the civilian population of
Belgium. I am willing.

In the course of some errands this afternoon,
I dropped in on Baronne Lambert for a cup of
tea. The Baron came in and then Villalobar.
About two minutes later, Lambert was called
out of the room to speak with a German offi-
cer, who demanded that he accompany him
to headquarters. Villalobar went with him
to see what was up, and I stayed behind to
We stood by for
see if I could be of any use.
a little over half an hour, and then, when
Mme. Lambert could stand it no longer, I
jumped in my car and went down to see what
was happening. I found Villalobar on the
sidewalk, getting into his car. He was de-
pressed and said that he had been obliged to
leave the Baron with the Germans: that he was
suspected of nobody would say what, and that
the Germans were going to search the house.
I went back and had them all ready for the
shock of the invasion. They were standing by
for the search party, when in walked the Baron,
smiling broadly. They had sent him home
under guard of two armed men, and were to
search the house in the course of a few minutes.
While he was telling about it, two officers
arrived, profusely apologetic, and asked to be
shown over the Red Cross hospital, which
had been installed on the ground floor. They
were taken all through the place, and found
only a lot of German soldiers carrying off the
beds and other belongings. Then they searched
the Baron's private office and that of his son,
and withdrew after more excuses.

There was nothing to show for the whole performance, and nothing had been accomplished beyond making a lot of people nervous and apprehensive. That is the sort of thing that everybody is subject to these days, without any hope of redress. And, of course, this was the least serious thing that could happen.

On board S.S. "Princess Juliana," off Dover, Sunday, October 19, 1914.-Here we are again, coming into England in rain and fog. Up to the last minute, I was in great doubt as to whether we should come at all, but everything was finally straightened out and here we are.

Friday we spent in hard work, aggravated with many conferences. In the morning most of the German civil and military Government

« PreviousContinue »