ON THE wasim i UNIVERSITY 58.291 PRINTED AT THE CITY STEAM PRESS ESTABLISHMENT OF BELL & CO., 13 ADELAIDE STREET EAST, TORONTO. TABLE OF CASES REPORTED AND CITED. ... 250 9 A. PAGE Abbotts v Barry, 5 Moore 98, 2 Br. & B. 369....... 59 Abel v Hilts, Ch. Cham., The Referee 363 Abell v Glen, C L. Cham...... 126 Adams v Adam, L R. 14 Eq. 246.... 218 Addison v Cox, L R. 8 Ch. 76... 329 Abreny v Megilli.at, C P., Easter Term. 302 Alchin's Trusts, In re, L R. 14 Eq. 230.. 218 Alden v New York Central Railway, 12 Smith 102.. 174 Alexander v Vanderze, L R, 7 CP. (Ex. Ch.) 530.... 215 Allen v Atkinson, L R. 1 P. & D. 655, 20 L T R. N S. 404.... 132 Allen et al. v Chisholm, Q B. HT. 310 Allen v London SW. & RW., L R., 6 Q B. 65 172 Allgood v Blake, 21 W R: 63.... 250 Allgood v Blake, L R. 7 Ex. 330.... 216 Aloo, Exparte 11 Jur. 858... 250 Alrich v Cooper, 8 Ves. 392 156 Allsopp v Wheatcroft, L R. 25 Eq. 59. 301 Ambler v Boulton, L R. 14 Eq. 427. 219 Andrews, In re, L R., 8 Q B. 153. 325 Annesley v Earl of Anglesen, 17 St. Tr. 1276... 38 Anon Dyer, 6 A...... 319 Anon Dyer, 45 A ......348.. 350 anon Dyer, 66 347 Anon Dyer, 152. 346 Anon Godb, 2.. 349 Anon, 3 Leon 67.. 348 Anon, Moor 91 349 Anon, 3 N. P. C. 19 Dyer, 88 A.. 3 Ansell v Smith, C L. Cham., Mr. Dalton ... 191 Appeals from Court of Revision of Cobourg, Assessment Case. Boswell, Co. J........... 294 Appeals from Court of Revision of Kingston, Re-Assessment cases. Burrows, Co.J.. 259 Applegarth v Graham, 7 U C. C. P. 171.. 28 Appowel v Monnoux, Moor 97, 98. 848 Armitsted v Durham, 11 Beav. 423.. 53 Armstrong v Deedes, Ch. Cham., The Referec... 363 Armstrong v Stokes, L R. 7 Q B. 598.. 96 Armsworth v South Eastern Railway, 11 Jur. 758... 175 Arnold v Holbrook, L R. 8 Q B. 96.. 330 Arnot v Bradley, Com. Pleas, H T. 1873... 190 Ash, In re, L R. 7 Ch. 636 90 Ashley v Sedgwick, 21 W R. 455.. 306 Attorney-General v Campbell, L R. 5 H. L. 524..... 97 Attorney-General v Chelsea W. W. Co.-Fitzgibbon, 193 Attorney-General v Dakin, 18 W R. 1117............ 178 Attorney-General v McLachlin, 5 Prac. R. 73....... 250 Attorney-General v Ro lloff, 10 Ex. 84...... 142 Austin v Great Western Railway, L R. 2Q B. 442, .....178.. 203 Austin v Manchester, Sheffield &L R. W. 10 C B. 451........ 145 Australian Steam Navigation Co. v. L R., 4 P. C. 222 91 Aylesford v. Morris.... 314 Ayres v Harness, 1 Ohio 368... 46 B. B. & S. M., In re Attorneys, C L. Cham., 1871–Mr. Dalton....... 28 PAGE. Bain v McConnell, Ch. Cham. - The Referee....... 313 Bainbrigge v Baldeley, 12 Bew. 152. ..... 53 Baker v Black, 8 LT. Ex. 318.. 2 Baldwin v Casella, L R. 7 Ex. 325. 93 Bamford v Turnley, 3 Best & Smith, 75... 312 Bank of Commerce v White, C L. Cham.- Mr. Dalton. 191 Banks v Govdfa'low, 22 L T. R M S. 813 ; 5 L R. Q B. 519 319 Barfield v Loughborough, L R. 8 Ch. 1. 323 Baron v Husband, 4 B & Ad. 611, 612........ 53-62 Birrett v Power, 13 Jur. 153...... Bartlett v Wood, 9 W R. 817 307 Birton's Hill Coal Co. v Reid & McGuire.. 121 Bate, Ex rel. v Corporation of the City of Ottaw... Com. Pieas, H T. 1873.... 188 Bateman v City of Hamilton, Q B. HT. 309 Batut v Hartley, L R. 7 Q B. 591.. 90 Biyley v Manchester, S. & L. R. Co., L R. 7 C. P. 415... 96, 148, 148 Buyley v Manchester, S. & L. R. Co., L R. 8 C P. 148 ; 8. c. L R. 7C P. 415; 7 Am. Law Rev. 297. 328 Beadel v Perry, L R. 3 E 1. 485 : 15 Rep. N S. 345... 264 Beasley v D'Arcy Scholes & Loff, 403... 127 Beattie v Lord Ebury, L R. 7 Ch. 777..... 220 Beattie v Lord Ebury, (Notes of the Week, Aus. 10, 1872).. 23 Becher v Great Eastern Railway, L R. 5 Q B. 241. 82,146 Bechervaise v Lewis, L R. 7 C P. 372 91 Beckham v Drake, 9 M. & W. 95 ; 1 Wm. Saund, 477.. 18, 19, 20 Boegle v Wentz, 5 P. F. Smith 309.. 298 Behrens v Allen, 8 Jur. N S. 118.. 317 Bell v Cameron, 5th Sept. 1872... 52 Bemis y Wilder, 100 Mass. 446.... 348 Bennett v Herring, 3 C B. N S. 470 353 Benson v Welby, 2 Saund. 155, 6th Ed.; 2 Wm.'s Notes to Saund. 454. 844 Berry v Gibbons, L R. 15 Eq. 150..... 323 Berry v Taunton, Cro. Eliz. 331... 847 Bost and Another v Hill, 27 L T. N S. 490, Nov. 14, 1872... 126 Beulah Park Estate, In re. Sargood's Claim, L R. 15 Eq. 43.. 326 Bickerdike v Bollman, 1 T R. 405, 2 S M. L C. 45.. 61 Bingham v Allport, 1 N. & M. 393.................. 25 Bird v Brown, 4 Ex. 798 ....... 20 Birkett v Whitehaven Junction R. W., 4 H. & N. 730, 732.. 175 Birks v Allison, 9 Jur. N S. 691, 695 ; 13 C B. N S. 12, 23...... 153 Bishop of Winchester v Payne, 11 Ves. 103.. 313 Bissix v Bissix, 3 Burr. 1729. . 343 Blake v Midland R. W., 18 Ad. & EN. N S. 93. 175 Blake v Jarvis, 17 Grant, p. 204 40 Bleeker v Smith, 13 Wend. 330.. 358 Blower v Great Western R'y Co., L R. 7 C P. 655.... 213 Bolton v Corp. of Liverpool, 1 My & K. 88.......... 359 Booth v Alcock, 28 L T N S. 221. 203 Booth v Turle, 21 W R. 721 306 159. 328 301..... PAGE. PAGE. Bosanquet, Re. 2 Robart 577. 132 Carr v Lancashire & Yorkshire R. W., 7 Ex. 707..... 145 Rowen v Barlow, L R. 8 Ch. 171... 302 Carr v Moffatt, Ch. Cham.-January 4th, 1873, V. C. Bowen and Wife v Shears, N. S. R.. 56 52 Bowie v Buffalo, B. & G. RW.7C P. 191 143 Cary r Hills, L R. 15 Eq. 79.. 291, 325 Boyce v Rossborough, 6 H. of L., Cas. 4... 320 Caswell v Boston & Worcester Q. W., 98 Mass....... 208 Boyle v Tamlyn, 6 B, & C. 329 65 Cattanach v Urquhart, Chan. Cham.- The Referee, Boynton v Housler et al., U. S. R.. 297 Blake V, C.... 212 Bradbury v Hlotten, L R. 8 Er. 1... 301 C. Bradstreet & Son v Everson, Preston & Co., U. S. R. 161 Brecon Markets Co. v Neath & Brecon R'y Co., L R. Chalmers, In re Edwards, L R. 8 Ch. 289....... 390 8C P. (Ex. Ch.) 157 ; s. c. L R. 7 C P. 550 ; 7 Chambers v Unger, C L. Cham.--Mr. Dalton... 212 Am. Law Rev. 495.. 330 170 Brett v Smith, 1 PR. 309.. 226 Chamberlayne v Brockett, L R. 8 Ch. 200.. Bridges v North London R. W. Co., LR. 6Q 3. 377. 205 Chanter v Leese, 4 M. & W. 295. 18 Briggs, Ex parte, 18 L. JC P. 184.. 26 325 Briggs v Grand Trunk R., 24 U C. Q B. 510........ 78 236 Brinsmead v Harrison, L R. 7 C P. (Ex. Ch.) 547 : Chapple v Durston, 1 Cromp & J. 9.... ..... 156 8. c. LR. 6 C P. 581 ; 6 Am. Law Rev. 495...... 218 Charitable Corp. v Sutton, 3 Atk. 400., 259; 7 Beav. Brinsmead v Harrison, L R. 7 C P. 553. .... 343 184 Bristol v Winsmore, 1 B. & C. 514... 58 7 British & Amer. Telegraph Co. v Albion Bank, L R. Cheltenham Waggon Company, L R. 8 Eq. 580. .... 7 7 Ex. 122. and not to 5 Ir. LT R. 192.......... 59 Cherry v Thompson, L R. 7 Q B. 573.. 93, 334 British & American Tel. Co. v Colson, L R. 6 Ex. Childers v Wooler, 2 E & E. 287. 61 108 76, 135 Childs v Great Western RW. 6 U C. C. P 291....... 149 British & American Telegraph Co., ReL R.14 Eq. 316 214 Chipman v Emeric, 5 Cal. 49.... 356 Bronte Harbour y White, C P. Easter Term........ 362 Chorlton v Lings, 17 W. R. 291.. 250 Brooke v Pickwick, 4 Bing 218.. Christie v Griggs, 2 Camp. 79.. 173 Brookman v Smith, L R. 7 Ex. (Ex. Ch.) 271, 274 ; Christofferson v Hansen, L R. 7 Q. B 509. 91 8. c. L R. 6 Am. Law Rev. 87. 93, 156 313 Browne v Collins, 21 W R. 222.. 143 363 Brown v Compton, 8 T R, 430. 343 Clarke v Clarke, L R, 1 Ch. app. 16, 13 L. T. R. N. S. Brown v Dollard, Ch. Cham., The Chancellor.. 313 432.... 128 Browne v Hope, L R. 14 Eq. 343....... 218 178 Brown v Lockhart, 4 Jur. 168... 250 338 Brown v Muller, L R. 7 Ex. 319.. Clarke v Willott, 1.. R. 7 Ex. 313.. 98 Browning v Beston, Plowd 131. 351 Cleare v Cleare, L R. 1 P & M. 655, 20 L T. R. N. Broughton & Marston v Knight et al., 28 L T. NS. 132 602.... 319 61 Brumfit v Bremner, 9 C B. NS. 1.... Cleland's Case, L R. 14 Eq. 387.. 220 Brummell v McPherson, 14 Ves. 173, 176........ 345-346 Clements Re, 17 Sol. J. 651..... 225 Bruty + G.T. R. Co., 32 U C. Q B. 66. 81, 83 00 Buchanan v Young et al, C P. ET....... 312 Clough v L & N. W. Ry., L R. 7 Ex. 26 ; 14 L J. Budge v Gummow, L R. 7 Ch. 719.. 222 Ex. 17, 20 W R. 189, 25 L T. N. 8 708.. 61 Buel v Fisher, Ch. Cham.---The Referee.. 160 215 Bull v Harper, Ch. Cham. --The Referee.. 159 Cochrane v Camack, 7 Ir. C L. R. 10... 338 Buller J., Dictum of, 1 B. & P. 101 n.......... 17 Cockle v Londen & S E. R. W. Co., L R. 7 C P. 721 Bullitt v Baird, Supra... 163 *(Ex. Ch.)..... 205 Burbank v Whitney, 24 Pick. 155.. 156 Cockle v London & South Eastern Ry. Co., L R. 7 Burgess v Great Western R. W., 32 L T. 70... 208 C P. (Ex. Ch.) 321 ; s. c. L R. 5 C P. 457 ; 5 Am. Burt v Hillyar, L R. 14 Eq. 160.. 92 Law Rev. 299...... 98 Butcher v London & S. W. R. W., 16 C B, 13........ 145 Cockerell v Aucompte, 26 L J. C. P. 194, 2C B. N. Buxton v North Eastern R. W. Co., 3 Q B. L R. 549. 210 S. 440,'184..... 258 Buxton v Rust, L R. 7 Ex. (Ex. Ch.) 279; 5. c. LR, Cogvill v Hart & N H. R. R.3 Gray 545. 347 7 Ex. 1; Am. Law Rev. 485..... 94 201 Cole, In re L R. 14 Eq. 178.... 90 C. Cole v Green, 6 M & G. 872... 28 Cahill v London & N. W. R. Co., 10 C B. N S. 154... 82 Collett v London & N. W. R. W. 16 Ad, & CH.U. N. S. Caldbeck v Boon, C P. Trin. T. 1872.......... 26 172-173 Calder v Dobell, L R. O C P. 486 20 Col. & Ind. C R. W. Co v Farrell, 31 Ind. 408...... 205 Calhoun v Thompson, 2 Moll. 237... 251 Colyear v Mulgrave, 2 Keen, 9; 5, C. B, N. S. 265, Cameron v Eagar, Ch. Cham. - The Referee 8 A. & E. 743. Ro. Abr. 1, 593 pl. 7 ; Y. B. 17 Camidge v Allenby, 6 B. & C. 385.. 92 28 984.... 383 01 18 Camp v The Tel. Co., 2 Metcalf Ry. 164.. 135 ... 218 Campbell v R. C. Bank, Ch. Cham.- The Referee.... 180 Commonwealth v Alger, 7 Cush. 73,,90. 341-342 Canliffe & Ormerod v Cross, 3 S. & T. 37 132 Commonwealth v Anthes, 5 Gray 212, 159 Cardiff v Piercy, Ir., Cir. R. 520... 250 158 Carlisle v Whaley, L R. 2 E. & I. App. 419. .......... 250 Commonwealth v Roby, 12 Pick 509.. 341 Carnegie v Rutherford, C L. Cham.-- Mr. Dalton.... 212 Commonwealth v Webster, 5 Cush. 306... 341 Carpue v London B. & S. CR'y, 5 Ad. & EN S. 747.. 173 Contract Corporation, In re, Gooch's Case L R. 14 Carr v Atkinson, L R. 14 Eq. 397 220 Eq. 454...... ..,,.. 214 PAGE. PAGE, 186..... 98 217 Commonwealth v Yorke, 9 Met. 111.... 341 Cooledze v Bank of Montreal, Pract. Ct., Wilson J. 237 Cooke v Forbes, 17 L T. R. N. S. 371, L R. 5 Eq. 128-130 Cooper v Chitty, 1 Burr 33.. 166 Cooper v Slade, 5 H. of L. 772.. 339 Cope v Barber, L R. 7 C P. 404.. 342 Coppinger v Bradley, 5 Ir. L R. 274.. 178 Coote v Whittington..... 291 61 94 County Judge of Perth & J. L. Robinson, 12 U C. C. P. 252.. 203 Coustou v Chapman, L R. 2 H L. Sc. 250. 221 Cox v Livingston, 2 W & S. 103.. 162 Cragoc v Jones, L R. 8 Ex. 81.. 329 .2297 Crawford v Curragh, 15 U C. C. P. 55.. 199 Credit Valley R. & County of Peel Bonus, Re C L. Cham.-Galt, J. 191 Crenver & Wheal, Abr. U M. Co., In re Wilson ex parte, L R. 8 Ch. 45.. 302 Creswick v Thompson, Ch. Cham., The Referee..... 192 Crocker v Old South Soc., 106 Mass. 489..... 358 Crofter v Metropolitan R. Co., L R. 1 C P. 300...... 78 Cross v Williams, 7 H & N. 675. 184-258 Crossley v Shaw, 2 W. Bl. 1088........ 274-341 Crump v Lambert, L R. 3 Fq. 409, 17 L T. R. N. S. 133 128 Cubiey's Trusts, 21 W. R. 170.. 37 Cullen v Doe, 11 Ad. & E. 1008. 57 Cummins v McLean et al, 2 Pike (Ark.) R. 402.. 163 (umming v Strand, 5 H & N. 95... 61 Currier's Co: v Corbett, 12 L T. R. N. S. 169, 13 L T. R. N. S. 154....... 128 Curteis Trusts. B. Re, L R. 14 Eq. 217 98 Curtis v Embury, L R. 7 Ex. 369........ 222 Curtis v Grand T. R. W., 12 U C. C. P. 90.......... 148 De Mattos v Saunders, L R. 7 C. P. 570............. 213 21 Dennis v Loring Hard. 27.... 348 Dent v Auction Mart Co., L R. 2 Eq. 278, 14 L T. R. N. S. 827. 123 Depeyster v Michael, 6 N. Y. 497.. 356 Desborough v Holmes, 1 F & F. 6.. 59 De Vitre v Detts, 21 W, R. 705 306 Dew v Clark, 1 llagg. 11.. 321 De Witte v Palin, L R. 14 Eq. 251. Diamond v Gray, 5 C L. J. N. S. 95.. 29 · Dickey v McCuilough, 2 W & S. 83.. 356 Dietrich v Pennsylvania A. R. R. Co., 8 C. L. J. N. S. 202... 79 Dingman v Austin. 102 Dixon v Evans, L R. 5 H. L 606 215 Dixon v Howiston, 16 LT. N. S. 295. 59 Dixon v Muckleston, L R. 8 Ch. 155. 825 Dixion v Yates, 5 B & Ad. 313.... 60 Doe v Bevan, 3 M & S. 353... 348 Doe v Bliss, 4 Taunt. 735-5.. 345-356 Doe v Butcher, Douglass 61 and 1 ; 2 Prest. Couv. 195-197... 351 Doe v Carter, 8 T. R.57. 343 Doe v Gladwin, 6 Q. B. 953.. 358 Doe v Jones, 5 Ex. ch. 498. 358 Doe v Meakin, 1 East 459.. 158 Doe v Pritchard, 5 B & Ad, 689, 765, 781........ 354-358 Doe v Rees, 4 B & C 384. 358 Doe y Salkeld Willis 676.. 343 Doe v Shewin, 3 Cambp. 134.. 858 Doe Smith, (1847) 5 Taurt 795.. 3. 3 Doe v Suckermuri, 5 A., & Ul. 712, 747-8.... 167, 312-3 Doe v Woodbridge, 9 B & C. 399. 358 Dore v Gray, 2 T. R. 303........ 339 Dougherty v blatthews, 35 Mo. 520. 356 Douglass, In re, L R. 7 Ch. 535..... 90 Douglass v Matting, 29 Iowa 498, 4 Am. R. 238...... 236 Dowling's Trusts, In re, L R. 14 Ex. 403... 216 Dudgeon v Patrick, 1 Miacq. H, Lds. 724. 75 Dugdale v Dugdale, L R. 14 Eq. 234.. 216 Duke y G. W. R. Co., 14 UC. Q. B. 377. 80 Dumpur v Syms, Cro. Eliz. 315, 4 Co. 119, 120.. 345-349 Dunday v The Hamilton & Milton Road Co.,18 Grant 311. 166 Dunkley v Ferrers, 11 C, B. 457.. 25 Dunn v Biriningham Canal Co., L R. 8 Q. B. (Ex. Ch.) 42 ; 8. C. L R. 7 Q. B. 244; 6 Am. Law Rev. 695.... 327 Dunn v Bf Lean, Ch. Cham., The Referee. 313 Durell v Pritchard, L R. 1 Ch. App. 214. 123 Durie v Hopwood, 7 C B. N. S. 835., 29 Dutton v Poole, 2 Lev 210., Vent. 318-322, approved by Lord Mansfield, Cowp. 413.. 17 D. 204 E. Dain v Gossage, C L. Ch.--Mr. Dalton.......... 165-103 307 Dalton v South Eastern R. W., 4 C B. N. B. 296.... 176 Daniel v Stephney, L R. 7 Ex. 327.. 93 Daniels v Metropolitan R. W. Co., L R. 3 C P. 591 (Ex. Ch.)....... Darley v Ouseley.... 234 Dawson v Manchester S & L. Ry.,5L T. N. S. 682.. 173 Dawson v Midland Ry. Co , L R. 8 Ex. 8........... 327 Davidson v Boyes, Ch. Cham., Spragge, C.... ....... 109 Davidson y Sage.. 170-199 Davis et al v McPherson, Q. B. H. T.. SOS Davis v Great Western R. W., 20 U C. Q. B. 27... 148 Davis v Kennedy, Ir. L. R. 3 Eq. 58. 250 Davis v Moss, 38 Pa. St. 346-353.. 351 Dean of St. Asaph's Case... 234 De Blaquiere v Armstrong, Ch. Cham., The Referee 363 De Blaquiere v Becket, 8 U C. C. P. 167. 28 Deeks v Stanhope, 1 Jur. N. S. 413.. 52-53 Deering v Lawler, 7 Ir. C. L. R. 333...... Deering v Lord Winchelsea, 1 Wh. & T. L. C. 89-95.. 20 Eadon v Jeffock, L R. 7 Ex. :379... 219 Eagles v Le Breton, L R. 15 Eq. 143.. 327 Earl of Lisborne v Davies, L R. 1 C. P. 264 ....... 153 Earl of Bristol v Wollsinore, 1 B & C. 514.. 60 Eastern Counties R. W. v Brown, 6 W. H. & G. 314 146 Edwards v London & N. W. R. W. ; LR. 5 C. P. 445 171 Egerton v Brownlow, 18 Jur 100.. 343 Elliott v Queen City Ass. Co., Ch. Cham , Sprayge,C. 159 Ellis v The l'elegraph Co., 13 Allen 226. 133 Englang v Cowley, L R. 8 Ex. 126. 330 Erskine v Deans.. 166 Escott û Escott, C L. Chem., 1872.-Mr. Dalton.... 60 Espley v Wilkes, L R. 7 Ex. 298.. 93 Everett v Collins, 2 Comp. 505.... 60 ...... 338 |